America’s Keynesian horror show


SUGGESTED ARTICLES

Tax and Fiscal Policy


I go to Singapore to teach every six months, which is always instructive. On this occasion, I discovered something I didn’t know and would never have guessed – that the growth rate in GDP over the most recent period had eased to a more accommodating 16.9%. It has, I admit, come down from the highest growth rate ever, but still you can get by with doubling national income every four or five years. These are growth rates so outlandish they have almost no logical meaning in economies so very different from Singapore’s.



These trips are also different because when I am there I rely in part on the International Herald Tribune for my news, which means I am relying in part on The New York Times, not something I often do. So what I also learned on this trip was that the destruction of the American economy and the jobs market has been so intense that even those who love the American President are forced now and then to draw attention to it.



On this occasion, amongst the columns from the usual gang of commentators, there was one by Bob Herbert. Under the title, “The Horror Show”, he began his column with these words:



“The employment situation in the United States is much worse than even the dismal numbers from last week’s jobless report would indicate.”



And there is no doubt they were dismal. Undoubtedly, as with the rest of the crew at the NYT, the reason for accurate reporting for a change is to help the Obama Administration sell its second stimulus package, something the rest of the country, exhibiting common sense, is reluctant to support. In his column, Herbert wrote:



 



“At some point we Americans are going to have to claw our way out of this denial. With 14.6 million people officially jobless, and 5.9 million who have stopped looking but say they want a job, and 8.5 million who are working part time but would like to work full time, you end up with nearly 30 million Americans who cannot find the work they want and desperately need….”



 



“…[T]here are now 3.4 million fewer private sector jobs in the U.S. than there were a decade ago.”



Given that, you would think that they might start to work out that Keynesianism is actually poison rather than a stimulus to faster growth and more jobs. But as Samuelson accurately observed, once something gets into the textbooks, it is almost impossible to get it out again.



Keynesian economics is the instruction manual for our economic elites which they use to trash the economy believing they are doing good. It is too much to hope they will eventually work out that leaving things to the market is an infinitely better way to proceed. But at least they might finally recognize that public spending on worthless projects is not the way to get an economy to grow.



You don’t have to be Einstein to recognise that insanity is doing the same thing over and over but expecting a different result, although as it happens it was Einstein who said it first. But if they really do apply a second stimulus in the US, with all the evidence of failure right before their eyes, in what other way would you describe such decisions or the people who made them?




4 thoughts on “America’s Keynesian horror show”

  1. Posted 16/08/2010 at 12:29 | Permalink

    IEA Blog

    IEA home page:

    – about

    – news

    – in the press

    – events

    – IEA publications

    – IEA journal

    – donate / join

    – merchandise

    – press releases

    – bookshop

    – receive our newsletter

    – links

    December 2010

    November 2010

    October 2010

    September 2010

    August 2010

    July 2010

    June 2010

    May 2010

    April 2010

    March 2010

    February 2010

    January 2010

    December 2009

    November 2009

    October 2009

    September 2009

    August 2009

    July 2009

    June 2009

    May 2009

    April 2009

    March 2009

    February 2009

    January 2009

    December 2008

    November 2008

    October 2008

    September 2008

    Culture

    Defence

    Development

    Economic history

    Economic theory

    education

    Environment and transport

    European Union

    Financial regulation

    Fiscal policy

    Health

    IEA

    Labour markets

    Law and economics

    Links

    Monetary policy

    Morality and markets

    Policing

    Political economy

    regulation

    Uncategorized

    Unemployment

    Welfare

    Let’s hope these actors are acting!

    A superb critique of “The Spirit Level”

    The Horror Show

    Barack Obama

    employment

    fiscal stimulus

    Keynesianism

    second stimulus

    Steven Kates

    US economy

    Economic theory

    Political economy

    RSS 2.0

    August 16th, 2010 at 1:29 pm

    Correct me if I’m wrong but Keynes said that you should “pay a man to dig a ditch and pay him to fill it back in”. The idea being that putting people to work would jump start the economy.

    The money hasn’t been spent that way. A good example – St Louis County has a smoking rate of 18% which is below the national average. It was awarded 7.6 million dollars for ad campaigns, lobbying and public outreach. This will only employ a few people for less than two years.

    Most of the money is going to advertising that smoking is bad. Up next – ten million for a public advertising campaign that the sky is blue.
    The rest of the money will pay for the government to lobby itself.

    August 16th, 2010 at 4:52 pm

    A intoxicação keynesiana « O Insurgente

    August 17th, 2010 at 2:01 pm

    Twitter Trackbacks for IEA Blog » Blog Archive » America’s Keynesian horror show [iea.org.uk] on Topsy.com

    August 17th, 2010 at 3:39 pm

    RSS

    [email protected]

    site by politicos design: campaigning online with political & mp websites

  2. Posted 16/08/2010 at 15:52 | Permalink

    IEA Blog

    IEA home page:

    – about

    – news

    – in the press

    – events

    – IEA publications

    – IEA journal

    – donate / join

    – merchandise

    – press releases

    – bookshop

    – receive our newsletter

    – links

    December 2010

    November 2010

    October 2010

    September 2010

    August 2010

    July 2010

    June 2010

    May 2010

    April 2010

    March 2010

    February 2010

    January 2010

    December 2009

    November 2009

    October 2009

    September 2009

    August 2009

    July 2009

    June 2009

    May 2009

    April 2009

    March 2009

    February 2009

    January 2009

    December 2008

    November 2008

    October 2008

    September 2008

    Culture

    Defence

    Development

    Economic history

    Economic theory

    education

    Environment and transport

    European Union

    Financial regulation

    Fiscal policy

    Health

    IEA

    Labour markets

    Law and economics

    Links

    Monetary policy

    Morality and markets

    Policing

    Political economy

    regulation

    Uncategorized

    Unemployment

    Welfare

    Let’s hope these actors are acting!

    A superb critique of “The Spirit Level”

    The Horror Show

    Barack Obama

    employment

    fiscal stimulus

    Keynesianism

    second stimulus

    Steven Kates

    US economy

    Economic theory

    Political economy

    RSS 2.0

    August 16th, 2010 at 1:29 pm

    August 16th, 2010 at 4:52 pm

    Other problem with Keynesianism is it creates armies of beurocrats.
    They then justify their positions by over regulation.
    The result ,they bankrupt the nation,then make life hell for everybody.

    See ,fall of the former Soviet Union.
    They laugh at the west now ,as they see the west making the same mistakes that they themselves once did.

    A intoxicação keynesiana « O Insurgente

    August 17th, 2010 at 2:01 pm

    Twitter Trackbacks for IEA Blog » Blog Archive » America’s Keynesian horror show [iea.org.uk] on Topsy.com

    August 17th, 2010 at 3:39 pm

    RSS

    [email protected]

    site by politicos design: campaigning online with political & mp websites

  3. Posted 17/08/2010 at 13:01 | Permalink

    IEA Blog

    IEA home page:

    – about

    – news

    – in the press

    – events

    – IEA publications

    – IEA journal

    – donate / join

    – merchandise

    – press releases

    – bookshop

    – receive our newsletter

    – links

    December 2010

    November 2010

    October 2010

    September 2010

    August 2010

    July 2010

    June 2010

    May 2010

    April 2010

    March 2010

    February 2010

    January 2010

    December 2009

    November 2009

    October 2009

    September 2009

    August 2009

    July 2009

    June 2009

    May 2009

    April 2009

    March 2009

    February 2009

    January 2009

    December 2008

    November 2008

    October 2008

    September 2008

    Culture

    Defence

    Development

    Economic history

    Economic theory

    education

    Environment and transport

    European Union

    Financial regulation

    Fiscal policy

    Health

    IEA

    Labour markets

    Law and economics

    Links

    Monetary policy

    Morality and markets

    Policing

    Political economy

    regulation

    Uncategorized

    Unemployment

    Welfare

    Let’s hope these actors are acting!

    A superb critique of “The Spirit Level”

    The Horror Show

    Barack Obama

    employment

    fiscal stimulus

    Keynesianism

    second stimulus

    Steven Kates

    US economy

    Economic theory

    Political economy

    RSS 2.0

    August 16th, 2010 at 1:29 pm

    August 16th, 2010 at 4:52 pm

    A intoxicação keynesiana « O Insurgente

    August 17th, 2010 at 2:01 pm

    […] Filed under: Economia,Internacional,Media,Política — André Azevedo Alves @ 14:00 America’s Keynesian horror show. Por Steven Kates. Keynesian economics is the instruction manual for our economic elites which they […]

    Twitter Trackbacks for IEA Blog » Blog Archive » America’s Keynesian horror show [iea.org.uk] on Topsy.com

    August 17th, 2010 at 3:39 pm

    RSS

    [email protected]

    site by politicos design: campaigning online with political & mp websites

  4. Posted 17/08/2010 at 14:39 | Permalink

    IEA Blog

    IEA home page:

    – about

    – news

    – in the press

    – events

    – IEA publications

    – IEA journal

    – donate / join

    – merchandise

    – press releases

    – bookshop

    – receive our newsletter

    – links

    December 2010

    November 2010

    October 2010

    September 2010

    August 2010

    July 2010

    June 2010

    May 2010

    April 2010

    March 2010

    February 2010

    January 2010

    December 2009

    November 2009

    October 2009

    September 2009

    August 2009

    July 2009

    June 2009

    May 2009

    April 2009

    March 2009

    February 2009

    January 2009

    December 2008

    November 2008

    October 2008

    September 2008

    Culture

    Defence

    Development

    Economic history

    Economic theory

    education

    Environment and transport

    European Union

    Financial regulation

    Fiscal policy

    Health

    IEA

    Labour markets

    Law and economics

    Links

    Monetary policy

    Morality and markets

    Policing

    Political economy

    regulation

    Uncategorized

    Unemployment

    Welfare

    Let’s hope these actors are acting!

    A superb critique of “The Spirit Level”

    The Horror Show

    Barack Obama

    employment

    fiscal stimulus

    Keynesianism

    second stimulus

    Steven Kates

    US economy

    Economic theory

    Political economy

    RSS 2.0

    August 16th, 2010 at 1:29 pm

    August 16th, 2010 at 4:52 pm

    A intoxicação keynesiana « O Insurgente

    August 17th, 2010 at 2:01 pm

    Twitter Trackbacks for IEA Blog » Blog Archive » America’s Keynesian horror show [iea.org.uk] on Topsy.com

    August 17th, 2010 at 3:39 pm

    […] IEA Blog » Blog Archive » America’s Keynesian horror show blog.iea.org.uk/?p=3969 – view page – cached I go to Singapore to teach every six months, which is always instructive. On this occasion, I discovered something I didn’t know and would never have guessed – that the growth rate in GDP over the most recent period had eased to a more accommodating 16.9%. It has, I admit, come down from the highest growth rate ever, but still you can get by with doubling national income every four or five… Read moreI go to Singapore to teach every six months, which is always instructive. On this occasion, I discovered something I didn’t know and would never have guessed – that the growth rate in GDP over the most recent period had eased to a more accommodating 16.9%. It has, I admit, come down from the highest growth rate ever, but still you can get by with doubling national income every four or five years. These are growth rates so outlandish they have almost no logical meaning in economies so very different from Singapore’s. View page Tweets about this link […]

    RSS

    [email protected]

    site by politicos design: campaigning online with political & mp websites

Comments are closed.


SIGN UP FOR IEA EMAILS